Visitor's Comments


Visitors' Comments on Tutorial: AHP



We have 15 comments on this tutorial
Suggestion > AHP excel template (date: 2010-05-03)
By Klaus Goepel
Dear Kardi, appreciate your tutorial and work put on-line, thank you! Was especially interested in AHP and learnt more about the method on your page. I have developed an excel sheet for it, which can be used for up to 8 elements - no makro. I also put a short video presentation on my youtube channel bpmsg. (http://www.youtube.com/bpmsg). I dont mind if you would put the excel template on-line, maube with a link to my channel. But please have a look at the template first. I\'ll send if you are interested and reply to my e-mail. Regards, Klaus
rate up: 203 | rate down: 103 | last rated date: 2017-12-16
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Question > AHP for group averages (date: 2010-05-21)
By Eric Stonebraker
Hi Kardi-First of all, I appreciate your Web site on AHP. Great stuff. I am trying to use AHP for finding how groups of 5-10 people feel about certain topics. I am finding that the variety of responses sometimes leads to CR responses of greater than .10 - the threshold you suggest. For the groups, i have averaged the responses for each pairwise comparison. I have come across the GMM and WAMM methods for averaging responses for large groups with dissenting opinions. I haven\'t quite understood it yet, but that may be of assistance. Do you have any suggestions for dealing with high CR values?
rate up: 193 | rate down: 93 | last rated date: 2017-12-13
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Answer > AHP for group averages (date: 2010-05-22)
By Kardi
Hi Eric, Saaty suggested a threshold of 10% for the CR values. In my opinion, the threshold of CR analogue to significant level of statistical analysis that related to confidence level of the analysis rather than a fixed value that everybody must follow. Having said that, if it is possible, the same respondents may also be asked again to reconsider their answers. You can use the CR as a feedback regarding their consistency.
rate up: 192 | rate down: 90 | last rated date: 2017-12-13
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Thank you > Thank you Mr. Teknomo (date: 2010-06-07)
By Jesus Calafat
Hello Mr. Teknomo, I guess you do not get messages like this one very often, but THANK YOU so much. I am writing my master\'s thesis and got to you page by chance looking for information about CR on AHP. I read by chance another page about alternative priorities and realized about a huge error on one of my thesis\' algorithms, which would have otherwise ruined and invalidated it. You explanation about composite priorities just saved my thesis. Kind regards, your contribution will be acknowledged. Jesus Calafat
rate up: 197 | rate down: 105 | last rated date: 2017-12-13
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Answer > Thank you Mr. Teknomo (date: 2010-06-08)
By Kardi
Hi Jesus Calafat,Thank you for let me know that my work has been useful for you. Please visit my tutorials again next time and spread the words about these tutorials to your friends
rate up: 197 | rate down: 88 | last rated date: 2017-12-13
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Question > AHP Scale (date: 2010-06-16)
By Carlos Barrios
We have a project approval committee conformed by 10 people. We want to use AHP for project ranking and I have made some web based questionnaire to be filled out by each decision maker. I am using a scale going for -9 up to +9 and for each pair wise comparison and I am averaging the 10 chosen numbers. Then I am introducing the gotten number in an AHP software. For the first test I got a CR = 11.2 %, which is close to 10%, the maximum allowed. Is this procedure OK? Thank you for your assistance. Carlos Barrios
rate up: 195 | rate down: 94 | last rated date: 2017-12-16
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Answer > AHP Scale (date: 2010-06-18)
By Kardi
Hi Carlos, AHP matrix must be positive matrix. Thus, you need to scale the negative value into 1 over that value. For group decision, many researchers recommended to use geometric mean rather than arithmetic mean for aggregation between actors. If you are not sure about the meaning of these averages, check my tutorial http://people.revoledu.com/kardi/tutorial/BasicMath/Average/index2.htm
rate up: 184 | rate down: 90 | last rated date: 2017-12-13
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Question > Negative CR (date: 2010-07-06)
By Alina
Is it possible to obtain a negative consistency ratio in AHP? Many thanks in advance for your feedback! Best regards, Alina
rate up: 183 | rate down: 103 | last rated date: 2017-12-13
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Answer > Negative CR (date: 2010-07-08)
By Kardi
Hi Alina, Negative CR is not possible and it may happen due to error in the approximation of eigen value. Remember that if you use MS Excel, it is only give you the approximation of eigen value, not the real one. Please use Matlab or mathematica. If you realy want to use Eigen value and Eigen vector for real problem using MS excel, I suggest you to install free Add Ins library matrix.xla from http://digilander.libero.it/foxes/SoftwareDownload.htm. It is a great program that you may use many matrix functions.
rate up: 199 | rate down: 96 | last rated date: 2017-12-13
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Suggestion > computer (date: 2010-09-29)
By Pour Yousefian Barfeh; Davood
thqnks
rate up: 138 | rate down: 96 | last rated date: 2017-12-15
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Question > Negative value on Consistency Ratio (date: 2010-12-19)
By Rajim Laymond
Hello Sir, Pardon, for posted same question(@Alina). I still confuse and don\'t understand with Negative value on Consistency Ratio. I build a web based php+mysql dss with AHP model. I did a validate by input value based on a tutorial and result is match between tutorial and system But sometimes, once input custom value, the Consistency Ratio got negative on this system. Would you please share me advice how to handle this thank you very much Rajim Laymond
rate up: 54 | rate down: 51 | last rated date: 2017-12-10
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Others > AHP (date: 2010-12-25)
By V. Tamilselvam
Excellent Tutorial on AHP. The lessions could have been posted also in provided in downloadable - pdf format. Any way thanks a lot.
rate up: 59 | rate down: 50 | last rated date: 2017-12-10
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Thank you > THANKS (date: 2011-01-14)
By hamid reza fazeli
my best regards to Mr Kardi Teknomo, that I\'ve learn much of his tutorials especially AHP
rate up: 61 | rate down: 60 | last rated date: 2017-12-10
Is this comment useful? yes | no
Answer > Environmental Sciences (date: 2015-03-14)
By Sudhir Kumar Singh
This best AHP site i found.
rate up: 197 | rate down: 108 | last rated date: 2017-12-10
Is this comment useful? yes | no
> (date: )
By
rate up: | rate down: 1 | last rated date: 2017-12-14
Is this comment useful? yes | no




Add Comment for tutorial : AHP

Please drop me a note if you find this tutorial is useful. I also welcome any suggestions to improve it. Let me know what worked for you and what didn't by answering the feedback form below. Sorry, I cannot help you to solve your assignment or homework. Check the FAQ before you post your question.

Rate the quality    Excellent  Good  Fair  Poor  Bad  
                             
Did this tutorial answer your inquiry? 
Why do you rated this tutorial this way? (optional)     
Your full name      
Your email          
You are including your email address 
to be used to respond to the question or comment
to be added to Revoledu mailing list to receive free news alerts (be the first to know about new or updated tutorials) Subject Topic Category Comment Keep this comment private Publish this comment Type this code: 5FGB3
Refresh your browser after Post Comment button to view your published comment.

These tutorial is copyrighted .